Informal land sales across Africa are being driven by the displacement of people who are desperately seeking some security where they can settle and farm to survive. This was especially obvious in Zimbabwe where the formal economy had collapsed and local people were returning to rural areas to farm and guarantee a food source.
These points emerged in discussion at the Living on the Margins conference, following a presentation on land transactions in Zimbabwe by University of Manchester poverty researcher Dr. Phil Woodhouse.Woodhouse presented a paper titled: “Vernacular land markets and rural poverty” which he co-wrote with colleague Admos Chimhowu. The paper focuses on land transactions in the Svosve Communal Area of Zimbabwe and highlights the insecurity of the legitimacy of these transactions. “The evidence we have from Svosve is that land redistribution has done little to produce equitable landholdings,” said Woodhouse, "in the context of widespread collapse in state services to small-scale producers, it seems likely that many of the poorest landholders will prove ‘too poor to farm’.”
What this means is that these informal land transactions will eventually result in a differentiation between rural labourers and capitalist farmers in communal areas, he said.
Using population figures for the Svosve district Woodhouse showed how dramatic the pressure for land was becoming. In 1900, just 2,000 people lived in the area but by 2002 this figure was nearly 20,000. The potential tax yield of this increasing number of people for the local authorities also motivated land sales.
Woodhouse quoted one interviewee as saying: “In Svosve the ‘selling’ and ‘renting out’ of land is so rampant that the only impediment to the whole process is space itself. If land could be reproduced then local administrative heads could have continued to receive new land occupiers”. The authors commented that the consequence of this linkage between tax revenue and land sales was that the purchasers of land were registered by the state and enjoyed “a degree of legitimacy”. “Albeit acquired through what remains – in law - an illegal process.”
Returning to South Africa Barbara Tapela, a researcher with locally based NGO Plaas presented a paper on agricultural commercialisation in small-scale irrigation schemes in the Limpopo Province. Tapela examined two schemes, one at Makuleke near the Kruger National Park and the other near Hereford. She concluded that neither programme was enjoying remarkable commercial success and that there needed to be a rethinking of the prevailing notion of development.
Grahamstown-based researcher Andrew Ainslee, who currently works for the Agricultural Research Council, presented a paper titled: "Band-aid, banditry or bricolage? Cattle production in the borderlands of the Eastern Cape province." Ainslie looked at cattle ownership on the communal lands in the Eastern Cape assessing its role in the “second” economy and questioning whether or not it could provide a route out of poverty. “The question is this: is current-day cattle ownership, on the increase in the communal lands of the Eastern Cape … or is it a constantly evolving, economically creative and culturally resonant response to severe and persistent structural disadvantage, or … a mixture of both?”
The conference has brought together the world’s leading thinkers on poverty with discussion focusing on whether or not it was possible to create policy that can reverse poverty and reduce the vulnerability of those involved in informal economic activity. It is co-hosted by UWC’s Programme for Land and Agrarian Studies, Isandla Institute and the Chronic Poverty Research Centre and sponosored by USAID, the Development Bank of Southern Africa and the National Research Foundation.
The information provided on this web site is not official U.S. government information, and does not represent the views or positions of the U.S. Agency for International Development or the U.S. Government. Link for official information on USAID and the PASSN team site on usaid.gov.
|