USAID's Poverty Analysis and Social Safety Net Team (PASSN) is supporting the Overseas Development Institute's (ODI) work on the Contribution of Circular Migration to Poverty Reduction in India and Vietnam. This work includes the development of a scoping study and workshops in India and Vietnam. The final report will be posted on PovertyFrontiers shortly.
Background
Circular migration, much of it seasonal, is now an integral part of the livelihood strategies pursued by a large number of poor people living in agriculturally marginal areas. For individual households, it may be a precursor to more permanent out-migration, or an enduring phenomenon in its own right. While the drivers of migration are complex and diverse, important ones include the lack of sufficient local employment (both farm and non-farm), land fragmentation, and better opportunities in other locations. Common destinations include urban centres and industrial parks where migrants work as street vendors, porters, labourers, industrial workers, brick-kiln workers, security guards and domestic servants. While the poor and unskilled appear to circulate closer to home, more skilled workers go farther for higher wages. Earnings and savings from migration also show tremendous variation by occupation, wage rates, expenses at the destination, contracting arrangements and debts. Some households barely manage to survive while others accumulate wealth over time, but what is clear is that most would be worse off if they were depending solely on local employment.
But poor migrants face a hostile policy and institutional environment. This is largely because migration is not properly understood at the policy level: temporary movements for work and the contribution of remittances to household budgets tend to be underestimated in national statistics. This is one of the reasons for the invisibility of temporary migrants and the neglect of rural-urban links in planning. Added to this are problems of urban and middle class prejudice which view poor rural migrants as a burden on towns and cities, without acknowledging the contribution that they make to the economy. An implicit aim of many rural development and poverty reduction programmes has been to stem migration by creating more employment locally. However this goal has remained elusive, especially in remote and poorly governed areas from where migration levels are high. The stance against migration has imposed unnecessary hardships on poor migrants who are routinely harassed by officials.
Summary
The potential of circular migration to reduce poverty in agriculturally marginal areas is now being discussed by leading donors and researchers. The purpose of the scoping study was to assess how much is already known and what we need to know for more effective policy design. The scoping study aimed to:
i. assess the scope and quality of existing reports on labour
ii. identify what might additionally be gleaned from existing qualitative and quantitative databases
iii. identify the questions that cannot be addressed from existing information, and propose how they might be tackled by fuller studies.
The scoping study sought to identify knowledge gaps and outline the types of further work needed to fill these gaps in order to improve public investment and service provision to support accumulative migration and provide social protection to the most vulnerable migrants.
The scoping study is a first step towards improving our understanding of circular migration.
The scoping study aims to locate and synthesize information related to five questions:- What are the broad kinds of labour migration, both seasonal/circular and more permanent, in the study areas by class, caste, gender and age?
- What proportion of household income is provided by each type of migration and how does this vary by the categories above?
- Which groups of people have been able to accumulate assets and skills through migration and why? Conversely which groups have been excluded from these positive outcomes and why?
- How can policy support more positive kinds of migration? In particular how can migrants who want to invest money in economic activity in their source areas be supported in terms of access to technical support, institutions, infrastructure and resources?
- How can policy reduce the costs and vulnerabilities faced by the poor in different kinds of migration? In particular what kinds of social protection will be needed for the most vulnerable migrants and their families?